Brothers Pizza, Brooklyn | Menu | Reviews

Welcome to Brothers Pizza in Brooklyn

Located at 647 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232, Brothers Pizza stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of traditional pizza making in the heart of New York City. For those who appreciate the craft of a well-made pie, this neighborhood establishment serves as a gathering place where quality ingredients and time-honored techniques come together. Whether you are a long-time resident of the area or a visitor exploring the vibrant streets of Brooklyn, Brothers Pizza offers a welcoming atmosphere that captures the authentic spirit of a classic local pizzeria.

The philosophy behind our kitchen is simple: respect the dough, source reliable ingredients, and maintain a consistent standard that our community can rely on. We believe that a great pizza is more than just a meal; it is a shared experience that brings people together. By focusing on the fundamentals of baking and maintaining a clean, inviting space, we strive to provide a dining experience that feels both familiar and satisfying. Every pizza that leaves our oven is prepared with care, reflecting our commitment to the culinary traditions that define this city.

Why Choose Brothers Pizza

Authentic Preparation: We prioritize the foundational elements of pizza making, ensuring that every crust is baked to the ideal texture and every topping is balanced to create a harmonious flavor profile.
Community Focus: Situated in the heart of Brooklyn, we take pride in being a reliable local staple where neighbors can connect over a quality meal in a relaxed, no-nonsense environment.
Consistent Quality: Our dedication to maintaining high standards means that you can expect the same level of attention and care in every order, whether you are stopping by for a quick slice or picking up a full pie for the family.
Classic Atmosphere: We maintain a straightforward, traditional pizzeria aesthetic that honors the history of the craft, providing a comfortable setting that focuses on the food above all else.

At Brothers Pizza, we understand that the best meals are often the simplest ones, provided they are made with integrity and passion. Our location on 4th Avenue is designed to be accessible and welcoming, serving as a reliable destination for anyone craving a genuine slice of New York style pizza. We invite you to visit us and experience the dedication we pour into our work every single day. It is our pleasure to serve the Brooklyn community and to continue the tradition of providing honest, delicious food to our neighbors and friends.

We believe that the strength of a local business lies in its relationship with the people it serves. By keeping our focus on the quality of our ingredients and the precision of our baking process, we aim to remain a cornerstone of the neighborhood for years to come. Thank you for considering Brothers Pizza for your next meal; we look forward to welcoming you soon and sharing our love for great pizza with you.

Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
Service options
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Serves local specialty
- Sports
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Beer
- Coffee
- Late-night food
- Quick bite
- Small plates
Dining options
- Breakfast
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Dessert
Amenities
Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- Kids' menu

Calzone and Rolls
- Meat Pinwheel $6.95
- Cheese Calzone $8.95
- Spinach Roll $8.50
- Sausage Roll $8.95
- Buffalo Chicken Roll $9.50
- Spinach Pinwheel $6.95
- Broccoli Roll $8.50
- Veggie Stromboli $8.95
- Chicken Roll $8.95
- Cheese And Meat Calzone $9.95
- Stromboli $9.50
Brother's Lunch Special
Baked Ziti Parmigiana Lunch Special
Chicken Parmigiana Lunch Special
Garlic And Oil Lunch Special
Meatballs Spaghetti Lunch Special
Lasagna Lunch Special
Eggplant Parmigiana Lunch Special
Penne Alfredo Sauce Lunch Special
Penne Vodka Sauce Lunch Special
Pizza Specials
- Two Small 14" Pies & 2-Liter Soda $33.95
- Two Large 16" Pies & 2-Liter Soda $37.90
Beverages
- 2- Liter Soda $4.95
- Water $1.50
- 20 Oz Soda $3.00
- 16 Oz Juice $3.50
- Stewart's $2.95
- Gatorade $3.50
- 16 Oz Snapple $3.00
- Jarritos $3.00
- 12 Oz Canned Soda $2.00
Meatless Dishes
- Baked Spinach Stuffed Shells Parmigiana $12.95
- Baked Stuffed Shells Parmigiana $11.95
- Cheese Tortellini Marinara Sauce $12.95
- Cheese Tortellini Alfredo $13.95
- Baked Cheese Ravioli Parmigiana $12.95
Salads
- Chicken Caesar Salad $13.95
- Antipasto Salad $11.95
- Caesar Salad $10.50
- Greek Salad $11.75
- Tossed Green Salad $7.50
Family Specials
- Lasagna Family Special $35.95
- Cheese Ravioli Family Special $31.95
- Eggplant Parmigiana Family Special $32.95
- Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Family Special $35.95
- Baked Ziti Family Special $30.95
- Penne With Vodka Sauce Family Special $34.95
- Eggplant Rollatini Family Special $35.95
- Penne With Alfredo Sauce Family Special $34.95
- Stuffed Shells Parmigiana Family Special $31.95
- Spaghetti Family Special $30.95
- Chicken Francese Family Special $37.95
- Ziti Family Special $30.95
- Salad Family Special $20.95
- Chicken Marsala Family Special $37.95
Burger
- Cheeseburger Deluxe $12.95
Specialty Dishes
- Ziti $10.25
- Prime Veal Parmigiana $17.95
- Shrimp Parmigiana $17.95
- Fried Calamari Special $16.95
- Eggplant Parmigiana $16.95
- Home-Baked Lasagna $14.95
- Fettuccine Alfredo $13.95
- Penne With Alfredo Sauce $13.95
- Home-Baked Lasagna With Meatballs $16.95
- Breast Of Chicken Parmigiana $17.95
- Calamari Marinara $16.95
- Baked Ziti Parmigiana With Sausage $17.95
- Eggplant Rollatini $16.95
- Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana With Baked Ziti $17.95
- Pasta With Pesto Sauce $13.95
- Home-Baked Lasagna With Sausage $16.95
- Spaghetti $10.25
- Chicken Marsala $17.95
- Baked Ziti Parmigiana With Meatballs $17.95
- Chicken Francese $17.95
- Baked Ziti Parmigiana $13.95
- Penne With Vodka Sauce $13.95
- Pasta Combo $16.50
Appetizers
- Fried Calamari $13.95
- Pepperoni Breadsticks $9.00
- Fried Zucchini Strips $8.95
- Rice Ball With Cheese $7.00
- Beef Patty $5.25
- Fried Shrimp (5) $9.95
- Mozzarella Sticks $8.95
- Jalapeño "Poppers" $8.95
- Garlic Knots With Sauce $4.00
- Fresh Mozzarella And Tomato $8.95
- Garlic Bread Parmigiana $6.95
- Garlic Bread $4.95
- Chicken Finger $12.95
- Bruschetta $8.25
- Chicken Soup $7.75
- Onion Rings $7.25
- Seasoned French Fries $6.50
- Buffalo Chicken Finger $13.75
- Boneless Chicken Wings $10.95
- Vegetable Soup $7.75
- Combo - Chicken Finger And French Fries $11.25
- Rice Ball $6.25
- Garlic Knots With Pepperoni And Cheese $5.50
- Buffalo Style Chicken Wings $12.95
Hot Heroes
- Grilled Chicken With Lettuce & Tomatoes $11.75
- Shrimp Parmigiana Hero $13.95
- Chicken Cutlet With Lettuce & Tomatoes $11.75
- Sausage And Peppers Parmigiana Hero $11.95
- Meatball Parmigiana Hero $11.95
- Sausage Parmigiana Hero $11.95
- Prime Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hero $12.95
- Sausage And Peppers Hero $11.50
- Breast Of Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero $11.95
- Eggplant Parmigiana Hero $11.95
- Spicy Chicken Parmigiana Hero $11.95
- Philly Steak Hero $12.95
Pizza
- 16" Large Pie $19.95
- White Pizza $23.95
- 14" Small Pie $17.95
- Fresh Mozzarella Pizza $24.95
- Chicken Marsala Pizza $26.95
- Brother Special Pizza $29.95
- Hawaiian Pizza $24.95
- Chicken Francese Pizza $26.95
- Chicken And Broccoli Pizza $26.95
- Chicago Pie $31.00
- Chicken Turkey Bacon & Ranch $28.95
- Chicken, Tomato, & Onion Pizza $25.95
- BBQ Pizza $26.95
- Vegetarian Deluxe $29.95
- Grandma Square Pizza $27.95
- Meat Lover Pizza $31.00
- Buffalo Chicken Spicy Pizza $26.95
- Penne Alla Vodka Pizza $24.95
- Pesto Pizza $22.95
- Sicilian Square Pizza $26.95
- Crushed Tomato Pizza $27.00
- Baked Ziti Pizza $24.95
- Cauliflower Crust Pizza (10 Inch) $19.00
Dessert
- Cheesecake $5.95
- Tiramisu $5.95
- Haagen-Dazs Ice Cream $5.95
- Chocolate Mousse Cake $5.95
- Toasted Almond Cake $5.95
Extra
- Hot Sauce $1.00
- Dressing $0.75
- Red Crushed Pepper $0.50
- Garlic Powder $0.50
- Grated Cheese $0.75
- Oregano $0.50
- Marinara Sauce $0.50
Catering
- Caesar Salad (Half Tray ) $35.00
- Greek Salad (Full Tray ) $55.00
- Tossed Green Salad (Full Tray) $45.00
- Tossed Green Salad (Half Tray) $30.00
- Veal Parmigiana $55.00
- Veal Marsala $70.00
- Penne Alla Vodka $50.00
- Penne Alfredo $50.00
- Baked Ziti Parmigiana $45.00
- Chicken Parmigiana $65.00
- Sausage Peppers & Onions $60.00
- Fried Calamari $55.00
- Shrimp Parmigiana $75.00
- Meat Lasagna $70.00
- Eggplant Rollatini $55.00
- Baked Cheese Ravioli $50.00
- Veal Francese $70.00
- Chicken Francese $70.00
- Greek Salad (Half Tray ) $40.00
- Caesar Salad (Full Tray ) $50.00
- Eggplant Parmigiana $55.00
- Chicken Marsala $70.00
Menu Coupons
- Coupon 3 $40.95
- Coupon 2 $32.95
- Coupon 7 $52.95
- Coupon 4 $51.95
- Coupon 5 $32.95
- Coupon 6 $27.00

Christopher Michalski

23-04-2026

9.4 on the cheese Quick & tailored 10/5 Stars on the hospitality. Brothers is the real deal. Dili prepares food like it’s personal. Don’t forget Grandmas slice. Don't overthink it, just come eat. Order type Take out Price per person $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Noise level Quiet, easy to talk Wait time No wait

Lisa Lisa

23-04-2026

came across this place by accident but def glad i did great pizza and pasta def check them out Order … More

Jimmy Jimenez

23-04-2026

Brothers pizza has been in my rotation of pizza joints for a few years now, I can count on them to deliver a solid tasty pie that I’ll be satisfied with. Their extra cheese is legit but when I order from them I have to go with the breaded … More

Samuel J. Sanchez

23-04-2026

I've been going to Brothers Pizza for about 7 months. Everything I order is always fresh. Their pizza is delish, especially their mushroom and broccoli slices and square Sicilian slices. Their customer service is great and very attentive! … More

Ivana Copelli

23-04-2026

Only spot in the area that sells gluten free pizza ( cauliflower crust)! Very local clientele but staff is very nice. Not recommended to eat in but to take out More